Erotic Authors Association
|
Having served as an editor for nearly
a dozen different publishers over the past ten years or so, I've read all
kinds of dialogue and scenes—the good and the, um, bad. (And the really,
really bad, but that's another story.) One technique that many writers don't
take advantage of is using interesting physical beats in scenes. In a
perfect world, a beat will enhance any conflict in the scene, help to show
scene setting as the character interacts with the immediate area, and help
break up the dialogue into more manageable pieces. They can help to reveal
character, show a scene, and describe the setting in a way that flows
smoothly and organically between the dialogue.
Definitions
Beat- a physical beat is
action by a character on the page, usually interspersed with dialogue. Also
known as an action tag. If it’s a sequence of physical actions, then
it becomes an action scene. Beats, by their very nature, are interspersed
with dialogue to give readers some breathing room.
Dialogue tag: the "he said, she said" and its variations that identify
the speaker and how the dialogue is spoken. (Growled, whispered, hissed.)
Here's an example:
Maya gave him a tight glance.
“Sorry, Mr. Lettig, but this is what the caterer has available. Perhaps we
can stop on the way back and get—“
“Just get me some water then.” Shane turned away from her and walked on. The two little girls looked on—his daughters I guessed; they had his facial structure and skin tone—their eyes moving from Maya to him and back.
The group swirled around her as Maya stood in the barn’s aisle, the orange juice leaking out onto the concrete walkway, puddling around her shoes. I grabbed a watering hose.
“I’m sorry,” Maya said, her eyes brown and soft looking in the barn’s dim light.
“Wasn’t you that threw it. Looks to me like he’s a pain in the you-know-what.”
“I don’t usually get these assignments; I’m usually in the Miami office … Never mind.” Maya bent down and snagged the carton.
“You might want to move,” I said. I held up the hose nozzle.
“Sure. Um, trash can?”
“I’ll take it. We’re careful about anything that attracts flies. Go on.”
Maya tottered off and I felt sorry for her.
The beats here help to show where
this is taking place (a barn), has the characters moving around and taking
some action (picking up the OJ, grabbing a hose), and provide a bit of
concrete detail (Maya's brown eyes and the orange juice carton). They don't
reveal character, but in this case, with a minor walk-on like Maya, that's
not needed.
Some general tips:
1- You don’t want to write characters that go on and on, paragraph after
paragraph when speaking. Dialogue is a dialogue, not a monologue. The whole
purpose of dialogue is to have some interaction on the page, not a character
giving a lecture. Using beats offers readers some breathing room and
rhythm.
2- Dialogue that has no beats or action in between can feel too rushed or
relentless. There are times, of course, when relentless is exactly what
you want in dialogue—for scenes of tension, conflict, and quick action. But
for more everyday types of discussions, using physical beats can help show
each character’s personality, appearance, and how they interact with the
setting.
3- Using too many physical beats is just as wearing for the reader;
you’ll tire them out and force them to start jumping ahead to get to more
interesting action. Strive for a balance between beats that enhance a scene
and beats that show character. In general, not every line of dialogue needs
a beat or even a tag.
4- Physical beats should be specific to the character, not generic.
It's boring to read about characters that constantly sigh, comb back their
hair or light up cigarettes. None of these actions are especially revealing
or compelling to the reader. But, a character who fidgets with an eyebrow
piercing or who limps from having been bucked off a horse is a character
with a little something extra on the page.
5- Don't use beats from Character A in the middle of dialogue from
Character B. It's confusing and makes readers have to stop and think too
much. Having Jack say "blah blah blah" and Stan react with "beat beat beat"
is poor writing. Who said what and who is doing what? Which goes along
with….
6- As much as possible keep beats and tags to the end of dialogue lines.
It's all right to intersperse one in the middle, especially if it's an
interesting or dramatic beat, but don't do it too often. Quite often I read
about characters that Pause Dramatically in the middle of dialogue ("He
paused." And that's the whole beat. I had one author do it 92 times in one
book.) It's boring and done too often irritates your readers.
7- Beats for an activity that’s unusual (scuba diving or tuning up a
tractor) can be more extensive than everyday activities such as driving
a car or putting on make-up. Because some of the action has to be explained
(gently) it can go on a little longer than common actions.
8- The way your character performs the actions is just as important as
the actions themselves. Read that again; it's important. A man who is
packing up his grandmother's china collection by first gently swooshing the
plates in warm water and drying them with careful strokes clearly has
different emotions than a man who snatches the plates from the shelf and
half-heartedly wraps them in newspaper before tossing them into a box. Let
your beats do some of the work for you. Let them show the reader the subtext
of the story's action.
Here’s an example of beats used
poorly:
There was so much confusion with
his father’s estate, the eminent domain purchase, and the store’s debts.
“Is this okay to sign?” Felipe finally asked. “You been to college. What does this mean?”
Monique sat back." It's what we talked about on the phone." She glared at him. "The store’s only worth about ninety thousand now because the new highway is coming through that part of town. The state is taking the whole block.” She leaned forward, looking annoyed.
“And the check from the state?” Felipe asked.
“Is in my name because I’m a legal heir, too, and anything in your name is something that guy can attach later if he ever decides to sue you. Reggie says it’s best if you don’t have any assets until the statute of limitations runs out on his case.” Monique reached for her cigarettes.
“Which is when?” Felipe asked.
“2012. Six years for a civil suit.” Monique leaned forward.
Felipe had to ask for a pen from the guard. He bent over the forms and signed his name with his face carefully set—neutral.
This reveals almost nothing about
these characters, there are too many beats, the beats are boring, and they
don’t show the setting clearly.
And here's the published
version:
There was so much confusion with his father’s estate, the eminent domain purchase, and the store’s debts.
“Is this okay to sign?” he finally asked. “You been to college. What does this mean?”
Monique blew her bangs off her forehead with an angry puff. Through the thick glass her face looked distorted, ugly. “It’s what we talked about on the phone. The store’s only worth about ninety thousand now because the new highway is coming through that part of town. The state is taking the whole block.”
“And the check from the state?”
“Is in my name because I’m a legal heir, too, and anything in your name is something that guy can attach later if he ever decides to sue you. Reggie says it’s best if you don’t have any assets until the statute of limitations runs out on his case.”
“Which is when?”
“2012. Six years for a civil suit.”
Felipe had to ask for a pen
from the guard. He bent over the forms and signed his name with his face
carefully set—neutral. (From "Shepherd", published in Love in a Lock-Up
from StarBooks Press, and Rough Cut from Lethe Press.)
If you're having a hard time coming
up with physical beats consider using a THAD, a Talking Heads Avoidance
Device. This comes from character and has to relate to the person you’re
writing about. It can range from saddling up a horse to cooking a homemade
stew to adjusting a trolley on a garage door opener.
First, think of an activity your character(s) would do and that would fit into your storyline smoothly. It might be a hobby or part of their work life.
Second, list all the actions and
verbs associated with that activity.
Third, list the items/props for the activity.
Weave the action and props into the dialogue smoothly.
There you have it. Put your beats
to work for you. Let them show the readers not only what your characters are
doing but how they're feeling. Used correctly, physical beats enhance a
scene and let's readers imagine it clearly and specifically for themselves.
So, go ahead and beat em 'up—the right way.
This Website's content is labelled "Adults Only"
with the
Safe for Kids and SafeSurf
PICS content labelling systems.
(Details
of the Safe for Kids classification system. Details
of the SafeSurf classification system.)
Copyright © 2002-7 The EAA. All rights reserved.